[quote=".:|CamTro|:."]I just made the design of rating. Honestly I think 1-5 rating suits better. [img]http://orig08.deviantart.net/c47e/f/2015/245/d/0/mfgg_fangame_rating_by_o_camtroartist_o-d984z4s.png[/img] (Credit to Kritter, Hero, and Mario Silva)[/quote] I prefer the 5 stars being separate to the medal, it's a bit confusing to look at otherwise and the medal is essentially just an overall "Here's the medal you get" thing. It's also a bit shiny for my liking :whoops:

How would that space look like without a medal, btw? A big empty red circle wouldn't really be that nice to look at.

a question mark?

[quote=".:|CamTro|:."]I just made the design of rating. Honestly I think 1-5 rating suits better. [img]http://orig08.deviantart.net/c47e/f/2015/245/d/0/mfgg_fangame_rating_by_o_camtroartist_o-d984z4s.png[/img] (Credit to Kritter, Hero, and Mario Silva)[/quote] Looks neat but the background is very distracting.

[quote="DJ Coco"]How would that space look like without a medal, btw? A big empty red circle wouldn't really be that nice to look at.[/quote] Wouldn't it always have a medal of some sort? Just different colours for X amount of stars. I suppose if you mean when there's been no reviews yet, it'd just have a grayed out medal much the same as the stars are.

Instead of medals we could have it feature some of the current review animations, maybe even some new ones. Alternatively, I'd also recommend using a Mario face expressing how good the game is (similar to that guy on Newground). 1 stars = Mario looking to the floor in sadness 2 stars = Mario rubbing chin being skeptical 3 stars = Mario holding his hat, looking at the viewer with a slight smile 4 stars = Mario giving a thumbs up with a smile 5 stars = Mario in his jumping pose e.g. [img]http://i.imgur.com/5lkuowU.png[/img]

I like Coco's idea, but it should be Waluigi instead of Mario.

We could use Mario from Mario Party [url=http://www.spriters-resource.com/fullview/9058/]like here[/url]

[quote="HylianDev"]We could use Mario from Mario Party [url=http://www.spriters-resource.com/fullview/9058/]like here[/url][/quote]That is a heavily outdated Mario. Do modern Mario Party games also have these expressions? Else I guess we could just ask someone to sprite some custom ones. I am pretty sure we could get some volunteers.

maybe something like [url=http://www.mariowiki.com/File:Artwork_-_Mario_Circle.svg]these[/url] would work, but there's only like, two of them. someone would have to make more.

http://www.spriters-resource.com/ds/supermario64ds/sheet/6843/ perhaps these? wario fallen over would be a 1, shocked would be 2, standing could be 3, the first frame of wario laughing could be 4, and the second could be 5. i can understand how these would be a problem, though, since they're not mario

I still prefer 1/10... ;__;

[quote="[url=http://phpbb.mfgg.net/viewtopic.php?p=457725#p457725]LuigiM9[/url]"]http://www.spriters-resource.com/ds/supermario64ds/sheet/6843/ perhaps these? wario fallen over would be a 1, shocked would be 2, standing could be 3, the first frame of wario laughing could be 4, and the second could be 5. i can understand how these would be a problem, though, since they're not mario[/quote] this is not a bad idea tbh

[quote="SuperArthurBros"]I still prefer 1/10... ;__;[/quote][quote="Zero Kirby"]If you can provide an adequate argument that isn't just "I like 10-points better" then please do.[/quote]

The default should be Mario really. Make the site skinnable like the current website is, and launch it with Mario, Luigi, Wario etc recolour skins that have their own things on the review graphics. I much prefer the idea of having Mario to a star coin seeing it in action, makes it far less confusing than a gold, silver, bronze type system.

[quote="Kritter"]The default should be Mario really. Make the site skinnable like the current website is, and launch it with Mario, Luigi, Wario etc recolour skins that have their own things on the review graphics. I much prefer the idea of having Mario to a star coin seeing it in action, makes it far less confusing than a gold, silver, bronze type system.[/quote] Customize Rating?

[quote="[url=http://phpbb.mfgg.net/viewtopic.php?p=457731#p457731]Kritter[/url]"]Make the site skinnable like the current website is[/quote] for the record: the new mainsite will be an [i][b]extension of the forums[/b][/i]. it will use the same skin as the forums.

[quote="HylianDev"][quote="[url=http://phpbb.mfgg.net/viewtopic.php?p=457731#p457731]Kritter[/url]"]Make the site skinnable like the current website is[/quote] for the record: the new mainsite will be an [i][b]extension of the forums[/b][/i]. it will use the same skin as the forums.[/quote] One can only assume that the forums will be getting a 3.0 skin to match the new website. Better get to work on a Wario skin for the forums then, if you want Wario on those ratings :whoops: Really though, it should be Mario by default.

Or it could become Wario Fan Games Galaxy And we could just remove all games that don't feature Wario

[quote="[url=http://phpbb.mfgg.net/viewtopic.php?p=457743#p457743]King Piranha Plant[/url]"]Or it could become Wario Fan Games Galaxy And we could just remove all games that don't feature Wario[/quote] we are considering this heavily also: progress update I got locked out of the SVN that Guinea and I had. I haven't heard from Guinea in a while and I was motivated, so I started work over on it on my own. What I have here is progress. It's not a lot, it's not pretty yet, and I don't have any of the MFGG themes on here yet, but it is progress. I'm testing out having news posts from a certain forum show up on the main page. [spoiler][img]http://puu.sh/jYbyC/af0ab6d85c.jpg[/img][/spoiler] Yes, this is the mainsite. It's fully integrated with the forum's template, just instead of displaying the forums, it'll display your sprite sheets and/or gaems