Kritter wrote:
Colour won't change my opinion much, it'll just look like a palette swapped Sheena then.
Are you not used to critique?
"Critique."
This is not critique, this is nitpicking and dismissing a very important factor of the image,
Style. I've been through five years of art school. I know the difference between critique and being a pain in the patuckus, and you're doing the latter, not the former. Critique offers a neutral-toned, non-biased perspective on the work in an objective manner, and provides suggestions or ways to change it, not just "oh, it doesn't look right," or things of the sort. Critique is deliberate, thorough, and meticulous, considering the artist's intention, though
politiely bringing it into question if it is unclear. And given I have made myself very clear in my deliberate decision making whilst designing this piece, I can hardly call what you're offering as "critique."
Congratulations, by the way, you've turned what was meant to be a quick, fun, distraction from my current project into something more stressful than defending a blasted dissertation.
And just to prove a point, I did a quick bust sketch of the
same design, but in more Mario proportions.
Spoiler:
[quote="Kritter"]Colour won't change my opinion much, it'll just look like a palette swapped Sheena then.
Are you not used to critique?[/quote]
"Critique."
This is not critique, this is nitpicking and dismissing a very important factor of the image, [b]Style[/b]. I've been through five years of art school. I know the difference between critique and being a pain in the patuckus, and you're doing the latter, not the former. Critique offers a neutral-toned, non-biased perspective on the work in an objective manner, and provides suggestions or ways to change it, not just "oh, it doesn't look right," or things of the sort. Critique is deliberate, thorough, and meticulous, considering the artist's intention, though [i]politiely[/i] bringing it into question if it is unclear. And given I have made myself very clear in my deliberate decision making whilst designing this piece, I can hardly call what you're offering as "critique."
Congratulations, by the way, you've turned what was meant to be a quick, fun, distraction from my current project into something more stressful than defending a blasted dissertation.
And just to prove a point, I did a quick bust sketch of the [b]same design[/b], but in more Mario proportions.
[spoiler][img]http://i.imgur.com/PUPigBQ.png[/img][/spoiler]