we were the first people to contribute tiles to the collab and i'm fairly certain we both contributed more than one if this one is from early 2014 then we might as well start over

We can't really blame the organizers for this. I helped run one before, and it seemed like no matter how many times I tried to get it going again it didn't really work out very well. It would be nice for the collab organizers to be more involved (as in, trying, at least once every 2 weeks or so, to garner interest), but ultimately they can't force anyone to contribute, and we shouldn't. I mean I tried getting it going myself, that's why I contributed so late. But unless someone else follows up the momentum is lost. (by the way, my tile still isn't in the collab yet.) I dunno, I feel like this could be completed, but yeah, if we do start over, a smaller collab would be much preferred.

I wouldn't mind contributing myself--it's just that the collab is so large. I'm in favor of scrapping this one and starting anew. An alternative would be to split the existing one into two or more collabs so that tiles made in the past are preserved.

I think I made two tiles awhile back, but never submitted them. If I can find them, I'll post them here.

This is a great looking collab so far!

Just added a poll regarding the continuation of this collab.

I have a question, are we still allowed to claim and make tiles? If so, then may I claim 1 and 4? [size=50]BTW, I can't view who finished the tiles of the collab, because clicking on the spoiler button won't work.[/size]

Sorry to double post, but I finished 1 and 4. I based it off of [url=http://static.planetminecraft.com/files/resource_media/screenshot/1340/Castle_6487468.jpg]this[/url]. [img]http://www.quintonland.com/MFGG/qnova_tiles_1_4.PNG[/img]

The next collab should definitely be smaller, it's pretty clear that people only want to submit so many times to something that doesn't feel like it's being contributed to.

Just fixed that un-openable spoiler and updated the main image

Is it okay if I go ahead and claim 20? Yes, I know that it is claimed by MurphMario, but it's been over a week since he has claimed that tile.

I finished 20 now, which is the one that has the brown gear on it. [img]http://www.quintonland.com/MFGG/qnova_tiles_20.PNG[/img] Well, I guess we've completed all the grass land tiles now! :biggrin:

Why don't we just let Q-Nova choose anything he wants? Nobody else seems like they want to do anything.

So what are we going to do now that more people supported continuing the project rather than restarting on a smaller scale? Are people going to spontaneously contribute?

I know we're supposed to claim tiles before we work on them, but since nobody seems to work on this anymore I went ahead and made 81. [img]http://i1277.photobucket.com/albums/y499/Blutorus/iso81_zpsdnnogoyn.png[/img] And on a different note, how come nobody's even touched this topic besides Q-Nova when people wanted this to keep going?

Nice to see people are still working on this. I'd really like to see this finished.

I almost forgot about this. Anyway, I'll claim 2, 5, and 9.

Alright, I finished 2, 5, and 9. Here's how it looked: [img]http://www.quintonland.com/MFGG/qnova_tiles_2_5_9.PNG[/img]

38 [img]http://i.imgur.com/DEAcmix.png[/img] EDIT: 40 [img]http://i.imgur.com/L0DwJtf.png[/img]

I'm gonna go ahead and claim 3, 8, and 12 now.