Hi there, I'm trying to make (yet another) grassland tileset. I'd like it to be somewhat unique. There's no decorations for the moment, I'd like your opinion before making some. [img]http://www.zupimages.net/up/17/03/346r.gif[/img] Thank you ~ :D

It looks fine to me, but maybe you could make the waves in the ground have no outline. :)

Like this ? [img]http://www.zupimages.net/up/17/03/52be.png[/img]

Exactly! It looks great to me. Now, the last thing should be darkening the brightest line running down the right corner of the pipe.

Is it better that way ? [img]http://www.zupimages.net/up/17/03/luhs.png[/img]

I meant the line on the [i]right corner[/i] of the sprite... :whoops:

That looks really great, Simpson55! I love the colors you used. :thumbsup: The only negative things I can add is the shading of the ground tiles. They appear to have banding (which is basically shading that is just directly based off of a shape), which doesn't really make it look natural and instead looks flat. Maybe you could try to only shade areas where you think must really need it. Also, I find it weird that the waves just get cut off in certain areas. I think adding some shades on the sides would make the waves in certain areas not look cut off anymore.

I actually don't really like this waves motif... Here's another one. I'd like the ground to look like fabric. [img]http://www.zupimages.net/up/17/03/cz95.png[/img] Of course it's very simple but that's actually what I wanted. I'm also going to add some decorations in the ground like plants and rocks.

The squares look way too small to me. :P What about this instead? [img]http://i68.tinypic.com/2h7mjw9.png[/img]

I actually tried to make the squares bigger but it looks like an eye exam :P Same goes when I try with lozenges : [img]http://www.zupimages.net/up/17/03/xzr9.png[/img] Is it just me or the high contrast causes the lines to look distorted ?

Actually, it's just that they aren't perfect lozenges, they look rounded and that's why it causes such effect. :P It's impossible to make tileable lozenges with a small space of 16x16...

I see, back to squares then ^^" btw, I made some "lego" trees for the scenery, is that a good idea? [img]http://www.zupimages.net/up/17/03/y26q.png[/img]

Unless if you are making toy-themed tileset. Lego trees generally don't fit very well with normal grassland theme. I would suggest something more natural, something similar to SM64 trees.

I was actually considering making a toy themed world, but I assume normal trees would still be useful.

SM64 trees are very common, I tried something... different? [img]http://www.zupimages.net/up/17/03/3ewv.gif[/img]

Those trees look very boring! Why not make their stripes a wavy shape or you could make the trees round or a trapezium shape?

Maybe the dark green stripes could remain straight, but sort of be one pixel thinner in every isometric dimension than the light green stripes? EDIT: Like thisish? Idk. [img]http://puu.sh/ttPqw/38c12d3767.png[/img]

Better? [img]http://www.zupimages.net/up/17/03/tdfb.gif[/img]

Looks good, but it could use some different shading. The way the light shines off of it makes it look like it's made of plastic.

That's intentional, like I said I'd like this world to look like it's made of materials like fabric and plastic.